Hybrid energy system and method

ABSTRACT

Various embodiments include a hybrid energy system that includes a combined cycle gas-turbine (CCGT) generator system configured to provide a up to a full-load power output and an energy storage device configured to store energy, and methods of operating such hybrid energy systems. A hybrid energy system includes a CCGT generator system configured to provide up to a full-load power output and a storage device for storing electric energy. The hybrid energy system includes a generator step-up transformer, in which the turbine generator, steam turbine generator and the storage device are electrically co-located on a low side of the step-up transformer. Methods of operation include controlling power output from the storage device and/or the CCGT system so that total power output by the CCGT system exhibits responses to up-power and down-power demand transients as if the system were a gas turbine-only power system.

CLAIM OF PRIORITY

This application is a continuation-in-part of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 15/844,902 entitled “HYBRID ENERGY SYSTEM AND METHOD” filed Dec. 18, 2017, which is a continuation-in-part of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 15/663,785 entitled “HYBRID ENERGY SYSTEM AND METHOD” filed Jul. 30, 2017, which is a continuation-in-part of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/497,685 entitled “HYBRID ENERGY SYSTEM AND METHOD” filed Sep. 26, 2014, now Pat. No. 9,722,426 issued Aug. 1, 2017, which claims the benefit of priority of U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 61/882,899, filed on Sep. 26, 2013 and U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 61/898,866, filed on Nov. 1, 2013. U.S. patent application Ser. No. 15/844,902 is also a continuation-in-part of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 15/543,832 entitled “HYBRID ENERGY SYSTEM AND METHOD” filed Jul. 14, 2017, which is a national stage entry of International Application No. PCT/US2015/052284 entitled “HYBRID ENERGY SYSTEM AND METHOD” filed Sep. 25, 2015, which is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/497,685 entitled “HYBRID ENERGY SYSTEM AND METHOD” filed Sep. 26, 2014, now Pat. No. 9,722,426 issued Aug. 1, 2017, which claims the benefit of priority of U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 61/882,899, filed on Sep. 26, 2013 and U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 61/898,866, filed on Nov. 1, 2013. The contents of all seven applications are herein incorporated by reference in their entirety.

BACKGROUND

Energy facilities are designed to provide energy to an electric grid in a reliable manner One example of an energy facility includes a gas fired generation system, such as a gas turbine generator (GTG), configured to provide energy to the electric grid while maintaining the frequency and voltage of the electric grid within acceptable limits, such as limits set by a government body, a regulatory body, transmission grid operations, or an energy facility. Electric grid demands change depending on a number of factors including weather, market demands, and other reliability driven events. The energy facility is typically designed to ramp up, including starting, or ramp down in response to these factors.

One example of an energy facility includes a combined cycle gas turbine (CCGT) generator system including one or more GTGs and a steam turbine generator operating off the GTG waste heat and configured to remain on-line a substantial majority of the time in order to respond to the electric grid reliability factors.

SUMMARY

The following is a brief summary describing a system and method to combine electric storage and a CCGT generator system into a single hybrid energy facility when viewed from the grid. The hybrid design is especially well suited for locations near load centers as it displaces the need to have thermal generation running in the local area on an almost continuous basis to provide the required inertia, energy and other services necessary to ensure grid reliability. The hybrid facility can provide the necessary reliability with a significantly reduced emissions profile and at a lower overall cost. The fast-acting hybrid facility also has excellent power conditioning and ramping capabilities which are vital to supporting the grid as well as the continued growth of renewables such as wind and solar. The hybrid energy system can be less onerous to the site than new gas-only projects of equivalent size. Further, a hybrid energy system can enable a CCGT generator system to be taken off line to reduce pollution when grid power demand is low, while the electric storage (e.g., a battery) enables fast response to increases in power demand while the CCGT generator system turbines are restarted. In some embodiments, power may be drawn from the electric storage to meet grid power demand after the gas turbine has responded to a power demand increase but while the steam turbine ramps up to meet the demand power output, thus compensating for turbine lag in the steam turbine generator portion of the CCGT generator system.

Various embodiments include systems and methods of operating a CCGT hybrid energy system that includes one or more gas-turbine generators (GTGs) with exhaust gases directed through a steam generator of a steam turbine generator (STG) that combined are configured to provide up to full-load power output and an energy storage device (e.g., a battery) configured to store energy. The CCGT hybrid energy system includes a generator step-up transformer, wherein the one or more gas-turbine generators and steam turbine generator (i.e., the CCGT generator system) and the energy storage device are electrically co-located on a low side of the generator step-up transformer. Methods of operation include controlling power output from the energy storage device and/or the CCGT generator system during scheduled and unscheduled grid power demands to achieve economic, electric system and environmental performance advantages.

Various embodiments include controlling the CCGT hybrid energy system by a Hybrid Management System to use energy from the energy storage device to supplement the power output of the CCGT generator system to compensate for turbine lag of the steam turbine generator responding to an increase in demand power so that the power output of the hybrid energy system follows the profile of a gas-turbine generator plant responding to the increase in demand power. Various embodiments also include controlling the hybrid energy system by a Hybrid Management System to direct excess energy generated by the CCGT generator system during down-power transients to charging the energy storage device so that the power output of the hybrid energy system follows the profile of a gas-turbine generator plant responding to a decrease in demand power.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

In the drawings, which are not necessarily drawn to scale, like numerals may describe similar components in different views. The drawings illustrate generally, by way of example, but not by way of limitation, various embodiments discussed in the present document.

FIG. 1 is a block diagram of one example of a hybrid energy system, according to the present disclosure.

FIG. 2 is a plot of one example of a hybrid energy system start profile, according to the present disclosure.

FIG. 3 is a plot of one example of an operation of the hybrid energy system, according to the present disclosure.

FIG. 4 illustrates a transient response of a hybrid energy system and gas turbine only system, according to the present disclosure.

FIG. 5 is an example hybrid generation grid support system response time plot.

FIG. 6 is a process flow diagram of an example Hybrid Management System feed forward process based on a day ahead expected delivery schedule.

FIG. 7 is a process flow diagram of an example Hybrid Management System process for providing power according to an expected delivery schedule.

FIG. 8 is a plot of example ramp trajectories that may be implemented in a hybrid energy system.

FIG. 9 is a process flow diagram of an example Hybrid Management System feedback process for providing real-time delivery of power.

FIG. 10A is a block diagram of one example of a hybrid energy system, according to the present disclosure.

FIG. 10B is a block diagram of one example of a CCGT hybrid energy system, according to the present disclosure.

FIG. 11 is a plot of a standard system using two gas turbine generators.

FIG. 12 is a plot of one example of a hybrid energy system, according to the present disclosure.

FIG. 13 is a plot of example ramp trajectories that may be implemented in a CCGT hybrid energy system according to some embodiments.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

The present inventors have recognized, among other things, that a problem to be solved can include reducing response times of a CCGT generator system, such as starting, ramping up, or ramping down, to an electric grid reliability factor. Energy facilities are typically designed to meet some combination of energy and electric grid reliability needs. Tradeoffs are typically made between one or more of size, amount of energy that can be produced, efficiency, time to start, rate of capability to ramp output up or down, ability to operate at low power output levels relative to maximum output levels, and ability to provide products that support reliability, such as ancillary services and reserves.

Ancillary services typically include operating reserves that are set aside for specific types of reliability events including, but not limited to: Regulating reserves—typically regulation is provided by synchronized generation and is dedicated to maintaining the frequency of the electric grid; Spinning reserves—typically provided from the unloaded portion of a synchronized generator, spinning reserves are immediately available to arrest a frequency excursion; Non-spinning reserves—typically provided by off-line generating units in a stand-by state that can start and ramp up their energy output within 10 minutes to restore electric grid frequency after it has been arrested by spinning reserves; Voltage support—typically provided by on-line generation, synchronous condensers and inverter systems, voltage support systems maintain electric grid voltage and reactive load (VAR); and Black-start—typically provided by energy facilities with the capability to start and generate electricity without aid from the electric grid. These units are available to re-start the electric grid following black-out conditions. The quality of these operating reserves has a direct impact on electric grid reliability.

In an example, the present subject matter can provide a solution to this problem, such as by a CCGT hybrid energy system that aggregates and integrates a storage system, such as a battery and a CCGT generator system, to combine the features of each into a responsive system. For example, the present subject matter provides hybrid energy systems configured to be responsive, so as to provide higher quality reserves by at least one of speed, rate, magnitude, and duration of the response to a transient event. By providing a responsive hybrid energy system, the present subject matter economically reduces response times of a CCGT generator system. Economically reducing response times includes at least one of reducing the overall start-up time or ramp time to the desired load, reducing the time to respond to a frequency disturbance, as described herein, and reducing the production of pollutants during start-up or ramping, resulting in higher quality reserves. In another example, the present subject matter includes a battery having substantially immediate discharge capability one or more GTGs that can rapidly start and a steam turbine generator system with a steam generator configured to receive exhaust gasses from the one or more GTGs and generate steam to drive the steam turbine generator, with the CCGT generator system and the battery configured to output power with a transient response profile desired by electric grid operators. In another example, the present subject matter can provide a solution to this problem, such as by a hybrid energy system having a CCGT generator system configured to have a fast-start, fast ramp capability in combination with a substantially immediate discharge capability from a storage device, such as a battery. Such examples provide the benefit of reducing the time the hybrid energy system responds to a change in electric grid demand.

The present inventors have further recognized that another problem to be solved can include reducing an amount of pollutants produced by an energy facility (such as a CCGT generator system) remaining on-line to respond to electric grid demands. In one example, the present subject matter can provide a solution to this problem, such as by a hybrid energy system that includes a storage system, such as a battery, that is synchronized and ready to respond to electric grid reliability factors, ramp up, and provide substantially immediate energy for a limited period of time and a GTG in a stand-by state (e.g., off-line but substantially immediately ready to start) which significantly reduces or eliminates the production of pollutants when the GTG is not designated to provide energy to the electric grid. An off-line GTG is considered to be a GTG in a non-power producing state. Benefits of such an example include staging the GTG for a fast-start response to an electric grid demand while reducing or eliminating the pollutant profile of the hybrid energy system when not providing energy to the electric grid. In a CCGT energy facility, exhaust gases from the gas turbine are piped through a heat exchanger to generate steam that is expanded through a steam turbine coupled to generator to generate additional electricity. By using the waste heat of the gas turbine to generate steam for the steam turbine, the overall thermal efficiency of the energy facility can be significantly increased. The gas turbine and the steam turbine may be coupled to a single generator or separate generators, with the two types of turbines, generator, heat exchangers and associated subsystems and components constituting a CCGT generator system. By coupling the storage system (e.g., a battery) to a CCGT generator system, both the gas turbine and the steam turbine (i.e., the CCGT generator system) may be taken off-line to reduce the pollutant profile in a non-power producing state, with power from the energy storage device then used to support a fast-start response to an electric grid demand while the gas turbine is brought back online followed by the steam turbine. In particular, power from the energy storage device may be used to support the electric grid demand during the turbine lag in the steam turbine portion of the CCGT that occurs after the gas turbine has reached its portion of the power demand while steam generation increases from the increased heat in the gas turbine exhaust gasses flowing through the heat exchanger the and the steam turbine comes up to speed to meet its portion of the power demand (see FIG. 13).

The present inventors have further recognized that another problem to be solved can include reducing the cost of providing reliability and energy services produced by an energy facility. Hydro-carbon based energy, such as burning or combusting of natural gas, can be an expensive, non-economic energy product approach, as compared to alternative forms of energy production. The present subject matter, in one example, can provide a solution to this problem, such as by leveraging market shifts to store energy in a storage device configured to substantially immediately discharge the energy to aid in the fast-start capability of the GTG, as well as provide energy to the electric grid in response to electric grid demands. In an example, the present subject matter can provide a solution to this problem, such as by remaining off-line so as to not produce energy when it is non-economical.

FIG. 1 shows one example of a block diagram of a hybrid energy system 10, including a generator step-up transformer 16, a GTG 12, and a storage device 14. The step-up transformer 16 is configured, in an example, to convert the output of the GTG 12, the storage device 14, or both, to a higher voltage prior to being provided to an electric grid 20, where electric grid impedance is represented by block 18. Although FIG. 1 shows only one GTG 12 and one storage device 14, examples are not so limited. For example, the hybrid energy system 10 can include one or more GTG 12 coupled to one or more storage devices 14. That is, the GTG 12 can be coupled to a plurality of the storage devices 14 or a plurality of the GTGs 12 can be coupled to a plurality of the storage devices 14, such as an energy storage bank. As shown, the storage device 14 is coupled to the GTG 12 and each are electrically co-located on a low-side 22 of the generator step-up transformer 16. In an example, the electrical co-location of the GTG 12 and the storage device 14 permits the hybrid energy system 10 to be operated as either a single generation or non-generation resource (e.g., storage) with an operating range from the full negative capacity of the one or more storage device to as much as the combined positive capacity of the storage device and the GTG. As discussed herein, electrically co-locating the GTG 12 and the storage device 14 allows for the faster responding inverter-rectifier 15 of the storage device 14 to aid the GTG response time in the event of electric grid frequency transients. Likewise, the same electrical co-location allows the inverter-rectifier 15 ability to ride through transients in electric grid voltages provided that the GTG 12 is on line.

In an example, the system 10 is located in multiple geographic locations, such that the GTG 12 can be separated from storage device 14. That is, the footprint of the hybrid energy facility is not limited to a single contiguous location, provided that the GTG 12 and the storage device 14 are electrically co-located at the same point on the electric grid 20 (e.g., the low side 22 of the step-up transformer 16).

GTG

The GTG 12 is configured to provide a power output, including up to a full-load power output. In an example, the GTG 12 includes a turbine, such as an aero-derivative or heavy-duty gas turbine having the full-load power output anywhere from about 10 MW to about 350 MW or more. The GTG 12, in an example, is configured for a fast start, such as about 20 minutes or less, about 10 minutes or less, about 5 minutes or less, or about 2 minutes or less. Starting the GTG 12 includes from the stand-by state (e.g., off-line but substantially immediately ready to start) to a desired load of the GTG, including up to full-load power output. Off-line includes, in an example, a non-power producing state of a GTG. In an example, the stand-by state of the GTG 12 includes the GTG 12 off-line, but substantially immediately ready to start. In an example, the GTG 12 includes an auto-start feature configured to start the GTG 12 in response to a frequency disturbance event. That is, in an example the hybrid energy system 10 is configured to provide the GTG 12 droop-like capability when off-line in response to a frequency disturbance event, such as a transient or decay in frequency. This example also allows for the inverter-rectifier 15 of the storage device to supply voltage support with the GTG 12 in the stand-by state. In an example, the GTG 12 can include a clutch between the gas turbine and the generator, so as to provide substantially synchronous condensing thereby delivering services such as short circuit duty. Such a configuration permits the system 10 to provide a substantially continuous and a substantially immediate response to electric grid transient voltage events, which can be accomplished without burning fuel or creating combustion emissions.

In some embodiments, the GTG 12 may implement super-low minimum power (Pmin) technology that may enable the GTG to maintain a gross Pmin of no greater than the total hybrid facility parasitic load, such as about 0.5 MW. By deploying the super-low Pmin technology in the GTG 12, the hybrid facility can be capable of having the gas turbine online serving parasitic loads while the net output of the facility is approximately zero MW or even negative, such as receiving some power from the grid for charging one or more batteries. This configuration allows for an immediate (e.g., “spinning reserve”) response from the entire facility without putting uneconomic or unwanted energy to the grid. Thus, this configuration enables the GTF to be online and synched to the grid without affecting the net power output to the grid.

Storage Device

The storage device 14 is configured to store energy. In an example, the storage device 14 includes a battery, such as a fast acting battery system, including an inverter-rectifier 15 to convert direct current (DC) energy being discharged from the storage device 14 to alternating current (AC) energy required by the electric grid 20 or AC energy being produced from either the electric grid 20 or the GTG 12 into DC energy stored in the storage device 14. In an example, the inverter-rectifier 15 is, but is not limited to, a four quadrant inverter. In an example, the storage device 14 is configured to respond or provide power (e.g., at least a portion of the stored energy) in about 60 seconds or less, about 30 seconds or less, about 10 seconds or less, about 5 seconds or less, about 2 seconds or less, 1.0 seconds or less, 0.5 seconds or less, or 0.1 seconds or less. In an example, the storage device 14 and associated inverter-rectifier is configured to receive (e.g., charge) and provide (e.g., discharge) energy.

In an example, the storage device 14 is configured to be charged by the electric grid 20, such as when electric grid market costs are lower than the cost of producing energy with the GTG 12 (e.g., the GTG charging cost). The grid market cost is at least one of the environmental, monetary, and other costs associated with obtaining power from the electric grid 20 and the GTG charging cost is at least one of the environmental, monetary, and other costs associated with producing power at a set fuel cost and heat rate of the GTG. In another example, the storage device 14 is configured to be charged by the GTG 12 when the electric grid market costs are more expensive than the cost of producing energy with the GTG 12. In an example, both the electric grid 20 and the GTG 12 can be used to charge the storage device 14. In an example, a portion or all of the GTG 12 output is converted to DC and delivered to a DC bus of the storage device 14 and the inverter-rectifier 15 to allow for further improvement in the primary frequency response, as described herein. Primary frequency response includes, for example, a response within about 30 seconds of the event that is meant to arrest a frequency disturbance. The GTG 12 includes, in an example, frequency response auto start capability, such that when the GTG 12 is in the stand-by state the output of the storage device 14 is substantially immediately increased and the GTG 12 auto starts in the event of an electric grid frequency decay or transient. In an example, the hybrid energy facility 10 includes a waste heat recovery generator. The waste heat recovery generator, in an example, is based upon the Organic Rankine Cycle and substantially all output is converted to DC and flows to the DC bus of the storage device inverter-rectifier 15.

In an example, the storage energy can be any capacity as long as the storage device 14 is capable of maintaining and providing the minimum stored energy necessary to provide primary frequency response during the time period while the GTG 12 is started and ramped to a desired load, such as an operator load set-point, up to and including full-load. In an example, the storage device 14 has an energy storage capacity of at least about 5% of the full-load power output up to about 100% of the full-load power output of the GTG 12. Further, the storage device 14, in an example, includes a plurality of inverter-rectifier 15 having at least 10% of the full-load power output of the GTG 12.

In another example, the storage device 14 has an energy storage capacity approximately equal to or greater than the full-load power output of the GTG 12. That is, the storage device 14 at least has, in an example, approximately the same immediate power discharge capability as the GTG 12 when started and fully loaded. As described herein, the storage device 14 provides a short-term substitution of the GTG 12 full generation capacity. In an example, the stored energy capacity of the storage device 14 is at least about 30 minutes, about 1 hour, about 1.5 hours, about 2 hours, or about 4 hours or longer of power discharge at or beyond the full-load power output of the GTG 12.

Hybrid Management System (HMS)

The hybrid energy system is governed by an HMS which ensures that the facility can deliver the desired product at the desired time in a cost-efficient mariner. The HMS may receive its Real Time (RT) dispatch instructions directly from the Operator. The Operator may be located remotely from the hybrid facility and may be a function of any entity, or automated system as may be defined in an off-take agreement. It may be the duty of the Operator to respond to the economic and reliability instructions from the grid operator. The HMS may be configured to follow the instruction as received by the Operator and ensure that the net output of the plant is at the instructed point at the instructed time. The HMS may do so in a manner that considers the remaining daily needs and economics. The HMS may integrate market knowledge, operational knowledge, or both to prepare the system so that it is positioned to efficiently respond to signals from the Operator in accordance with any off-take agreement that might exist.

The HMS may include feed-forward and feedback loops to govern at least one of the facility conditions, including state of charge (SOC) of the battery, start and stop the gas turbine (and a steam turbine in a CCGT generator system), and govern the ramp rate of the net plant output. The HMS can determine a number of factors, including: Excepted Delivery Schedules (EDS) from the market awards and schedules provided by the Operator; the timing for battery charge based upon market or contract prices; and the least cost method to deliver scheduled energy by optimizing information from the life-cycle costs and operational limits envelopes against the EDS and required ramp rates by product type. In this way, the HMS may function much like the embedded software in a hybrid vehicle when it responds to a signal from the accelerator or brake, except that the HMS has more anticipatory logic. The HMS will make decisions and issue instructions to start and stop the GTG (and a steam turbine in a CCGT generator system), charge the battery, and ramp the plant at specified ramp rates. The HMS can start and stop the gas turbine (and a steam turbine in a CCGT generator system) as required in such a way as to shape the output as required.

The hybrid energy system may also include power electronics associated with power conversion and balance of plant equipment, including the AC portion of the plant, controls, switchgear, and the like, some or all of which may be controlled or partially controlled by the HMS.

Configurations

In various embodiments, both the gas turbine and the battery inverter are connected on the low side of the same Generator Step-Up (GSU) transformer. This enable an immediate response from the inverter to grid frequency disturbances, and thus enables the GTG 12 to have increased ride-through capability during grid frequency disturbances when the GTG is operating in a minimum power mode.

In an example, a portion or all of the gas turbine output may be converted to direct current (DC) and delivered to a DC bus of the battery inverters to allow for even further improvement in the primary frequency response. Additionally, the gas turbine may be equipped with a frequency-response auto-start capability for those instances when the GTG 12 is not running The start times for the gas-fired turbine generator may be integrated into the ramp rate of the energy storage system such that the gas-fired turbine generator start time is non-apparent to the total facility output. Maintaining a gas-fired turbine generator gross Pmin of no greater than the total facility parasitic load allows the gas-fired turbine generator to be online and available for immediate response without affecting the hybrid facility net output and without requiring market uplifts for minimum load cost recovery.

The configurations described below are examples that use the system as described relative to FIG. 1.

Enhanced GTG (EGT)

In an example, the hybrid energy system 10 is configured to use the storage device 14 to enhance the operational characteristics of the GTG 12. For example, the stored energy capacity of the storage device 14 is used as spinning reserve and is used to provide initial primary frequency response while starting the GTG 14 from the stand-by state up to a desired load output of the hybrid energy system (e.g., operator load set-point), such as up to and including full-load power output. In an example, stand-by state includes a non-fuel burning mode, in which little fuel to no fuel is combusted. During periods when the electric grid 20 is operating within its normal operating limits, such as operating limits for frequency or voltage established by transmission or distribution operators, the GTG 12 is configured to remain in the stand-by state (e.g., off-line, but ready to substantially immediately start). In such an example, the storage device 14 remains on-line, and primary transient protection is provided by the stored energy and inverter-rectifier 15 of the storage device 14. For example, the hybrid energy system 10 may be configured to start the GTG 12 from the stand-by state to the desired load output, such as the full-load power output, in about 20 minutes or less, about 10 minutes or less, about 5 minutes or less, or in a about 2 minutes or less.

When an electric grid transient occurs, the stored energy of the storage device 14 is used for transient protection, such that the GTG 12 starts, such as substantially instantaneously and at least a portion of a stored energy of the storage device 14 is transferred to the electric grid. In the instance where the electric grid 20 requires additional economic energy, the gas fired generator can be started and loaded without the use of the storage device 14.

The storage output of the storage device 14 does not need to be additive to the GTG 12 output, but rather provides (e.g., substantially instantaneously) output until the GTG 12 can deliver the necessary output to provide a substantially similar ramp curve as the GTG 12 alone, as described herein. That is, the storage device 14 can be slaved to a total output of the hybrid energy system 10 such that the storage device 14 discharges the difference between the desired expected output if the GTG 12 was initially synchronized and the actual GTG output, on a net basis. For example, the EGT configuration enhances the GTG 12 such that the hybrid energy system is operated in a smooth, continuous fashion with a single monotonically increasing energy supply curve.

In an example, as opposed to being in the stand-by state, the GTG 12 is configured to operate at a minimum power output of less than about 5%, less than about 3%, or less than about 1% of the full-load power output of the GTG 12. The minimum power output is the minimum output at which the GTG 12 can stably operate. In such a configuration, for example, the storage device 14 has a stored energy capacity of at least about 5% of the full-load power output up to about 100% of the full-load power output of the GTG. In such an example, when an electric grid transient occurs, the stored energy of the storage device 14 is used for transient protection, such that the GTG 12 ramps, such as substantially instantaneously and at least a portion of a stored energy of the storage device 14 is transferred to the electric grid. In the instance where the electric grid 20 requires additional economic energy, the gas fired generator can be started and loaded without the use of the storage device 14.

FIG. 2 shows a plot 30 of one example of a hybrid energy system start profile, according to the present disclosure. The values represented in FIG. 2 are merely for example purposes and are not limiting. For example, FIG. 2 illustrates the start of the GTG (12, FIG. 1) and the subsequent ramping of the GTG in an EGT system configuration. In the plot 30, the y-axis represents power output in megawatts (MW) and the x-axis representing elapsed time in minutes. Although, specific power output, power storage, and times are shown, they are to be understood as exemplary only and do not limit the current disclosure. The hybrid energy system plotted in plot 20 includes a storage device with an energy storage capacity of at least about 10% of the full-load power output of the GTG. Further in the example plotted in FIG. 2, the storage device includes an inverter-rectifier having at least 20% of the full-load power output of the GTG 12.

At time T=0 minutes the hybrid energy system (10, FIG. 1) receives a command, such as detection of a transient event, market event, or the like, to start and ramp the GTG to a desired load 38 of 50 MW. In an example, the desired load 38 is a desired load output for the hybrid energy system or the desired load output of the GTG. The desired load 38 can be partial full-load output of the GTG or full-load output of the GTG. Further, as described above, the GTG is in the stand-by state. As shown by line 32, the storage device (14, FIG. 1) discharges at least a portion of the stored energy capacity substantially simultaneously to the delivery of a command to start the GTG. As shown in plot 30, a total hybrid energy system output 36 is substantially equal to the storage device output 32 from time T=0 minutes to T=3 minutes. That is, the storage device output 36 is equal to the total hybrid energy system output 36 when the GTG output 34 is zero MW (e.g., initiating a start sequence). The storage device output 32 from time T=0 minutes to time T=3 minutes follows a ramping profile (e.g., slope of 32) similar (e.g., continually increasing toward the desired load 38) to that as if the GTG were to ramp alone from an on-line mode and synchronized, such as a total hybrid energy system output 36. However, unlike the ramping of an on-line GTG, the discharge of the storage device does not result in the production of emissions, including, but not limited, to air pollutants, such as greenhouse gases. Further, substantially simultaneously to the storage device discharging at least a portion of its stored energy, the GTG initiates its start sequence, indicated by line 34.

As an example, shown by GTG output 34, the GTG generator synchronization, loading profile, and warm-up sequence is initiated at about time T=3 minutes until about time T=4 minutes. As shown, at time T=3 minutes the storage device reduces its output 32 as the GTG begins to provide positive GTG load output 34 to the total hybrid energy system output 36. The plot 30 illustrates a minimum standard for the ramp profile of the total hybrid energy system output 36. Alternatively, the storage device output 32 can maintain a substantially constant positive ramp profile (e.g., slope of 32) from time T=3 minutes to time T=4 minutes or can maintain a substantially constant storage device output 32 (e.g., slope of zero). In an example, the total hybrid energy system output 36 is continually increasing toward the desired load 38 or has a ramp profile with a slope of zero for 1 minute or less while ramping to the desired load output. At time T=4 minutes, the GTG has warmed-up sufficiently to continue ramping the output 34 to the desired GTG load 38. Substantially simultaneously, the storage device reduces the storage device output 32 until it is no longer discharging, while maintaining a continually increasing the hybrid energy system output 36 towards the desired storage load 38. As shown in FIG. 2, in an example, a total hybrid energy system is configured, such as the EGT configuration, to start the GTG from the stand-by-state state to the full-load power output and discharge at least a portion of the stored energy of the storage device at a hybrid ramp rate that substantially matches a gas turbine alone ramp rate. Thus, the HMS integrates the GTG start time into the ramp rate of the output of the energy storage system such that the GTG start time is non-apparent in the total facility output. In an example, the single composite power output response of the hybrid energy system may transition from about −50 MW to about 100 MW.

In this manner, the EGT configuration can provide substantially continuous and substantially immediate responses to electric grid transients and contingencies without at least a portion of the undesired attributes of unnecessary fuel burn, unwanted pollutants, and unrequired energy contributed by the typical gas fired generation units of the current electric grid. For example, reducing unwanted pollutants may include reducing the pollutant profile (e.g., pollutants produced per MW, time, or unit of fuel).

Enhanced Storage (ES)

In an example, the hybrid energy system (10, FIG. 1) is configured to use the GTG (12, FIG. 1) to supplement the storage device (14, FIG. 1), such as, for example, maintain a state of charge of the storage device during operation of the hybrid energy system, such that the faster responding storage device is available to respond to an electric grid frequency transient. In an example, a portion or all of the GTG output may be converted to DC and delivered to a DC bus of the storage device, such as the inverter-rectifier (15, FIG. 1), to allow for even improvement (e.g., faster) in the primary frequency response. Additionally, in an example the GTG is equipped with a frequency response auto start capability for instances when the GTG is in the stand-by state. In an example, the hybrid energy system includes a waste heat recovery generator.

The ES configuration includes, in an example, the stored energy capacity of the storage device approximately equal to or greater than the full-load power output of the GTG. That is, the storage device at least has, in an example, approximately the same immediate power discharge capability as the GTG when started and fully loaded. As described herein, the storage device provides a short-term substitution of the GTG full generation capacity. In an example, the stored energy capacity of the storage device is at least about 15 minutes, about 1 hour, about 1.5 hours, about 2 hours, or about 4 hours or longer of power discharge at or beyond the full-load power output of the GTG.

FIG. 3 shows a plot 40 of one example of an operation, such as regulation output, of the hybrid energy system, such as managing a state of charge of the storage device with the GTG, according to the present disclosure. The values represented by FIG. 3 and Table 1 are merely for example and are not limiting. In the plot 40, the left y-axis represents MW and pertains to lines 44, 46, and 48; the right y-axis represents MWh and pertains to line 42; the x-axis represents time in minutes and pertains to each line 42, 44, 46, and 48. As shown in FIG. 3, the GTG output 46, from about time T=1 minute to about time T=7 minutes is approximately a constant 25 MW. During this window of time (1 to 7 minutes) regulation ramping 48 varies significantly and randomly. In response to the varying regulation ramping 48, the storage device substantially immediately responds likewise in its discharge 44. For example, from time T=3 minutes to time T=4 minutes the regulation ramping 48 decreases and the storage device output 44 also decreases. This is accomplished by having the GTG output 46 in excess of the required regulation output. The excess energy is diverted to charging the storage device to maintain its state of charge 42 relatively constant at around 100 MWh Similarly, when the regulation ramping increases 48, for example from time T=4 minutes to time T=5 minutes, the storage device output 44 increases the output to match the demand. As can be seen in FIG. 3, this relationship holds true even with the overall hybrid energy system output increases from approximately 25 MW to approximately 44 MW. In an example, the storage device is configured to respond (e.g., substantially simultaneously) before the GTG when the regulation demand is detected during operation of the hybrid energy system. By maintaining the state of charge 42 of the storage device, the hybrid energy system is capable of substantially immediately responding to operations, such as regulation, while the GTG is on-line.

As shown in FIG. 3, during fluctuations in regulation ramping 48, the state of charge of the storage device 42 remains substantially constant, approximately 100 MWh. This is accomplished by the charging and discharging of the storage device in response to each of the changes of the regulation ramping 48. Table 1 titled “Managing State of Charge with the GTG in FIG. 3” corresponds to the plot 40 including state of charge 42, storage device output 44, GTG output 46, regulation ramping 48. As shown in Table 1, from time T=1 minute to time T=5 minutes, the desired GTG output is 24 MW, allowing the GTG, assuming a 50 MW GTG for this example, to operate at half-power. However, at time T=5 minutes the regulation ramping increases to 43.4 MW. As such, the storage device output is substantially immediately increased to 19.4 MW to provide output in addition to the GTG output of 24 MW, so as to provide the regulation ramping output of 43.4 MW (e.g., 19.4 MW+24 MW=43.4 MW). Due to the higher load requirements initiated by the regulation ramping at time T=5 minutes, the GTG output is increased to 40 MW from time T=6 minutes to time T=10 minutes as shown by the positive slope of line 46 in FIG. 3. During that GTG ramping time frame from time T=6 minutes to time T=10 minutes, the storage device continues to respond to any regulation ramping. For example, at time T=6 minutes the regulation ramping decreased to 21.9 MW. However, the GTG has already begun increasing its output above 24 MW. The GTG output in excess of the regulation ramping output of 21.9 MW is provided to the storage device to maintain the storage device state of charge. For example, the storage device output is decreased to −18.10 MW (e.g., charging) while the GTG output is 40 MW, so as to provide the regulation ramping of 21.9 MW at time T=6 minutes (e.g., 40 MW+(−18.1 MW)=21.9 MW).

Further, as shown in Table 1, from time T=1 to time T=15 the total regulation ramping output for the example was 9.12 MWh. Although the storage device is configured to respond first to regulation ramping the total output for the storage device was 0.45 MWh, while the gas turbine output was 8.67 MWh. As shown by FIG. 3 and the corresponding Table 1 below, the storage device does the fast acting regulation and the GTG maintains the state of charge on the storage device so that the storage device continues to responding at fast rate without the charge of the storage device being depleted.

TABLE 1 Managing State of Charge with the GTG in FIG. 3 Storage Storage Device Device GTG Regulation Storage State of Output Output Ramping Device GTG Regulation Charge Time 44 46 48 Output Output Ramping 42 (minute) (MW) (MW) (MW) (MWh) (MWh) (MWh) (MWh) 1 20.00 24.00 44.00 0.33 0.40 0.73 99.67 2 −25.00 24.00 −1.00 −0.42 0.40 −0.02 100.08 3 −2.20 24.00 21.80 −0.04 0.40 0.36 100.12 4 −30.00 24.00 −6.00 −0.50 0.40 −0.10 100.62 5 19.40 24.00 43.40 0.32 0.40 0.72 100.30 6 −18.10 40.00 21.90 −0.30 0.67 0.37 100.60 7 44.30 40.00 84.30 0.74 0.67 1.41 99.86 8 −50.00 40.00 −10.00 −0.83 0.67 −0.17 100.69 9 20.00 40.00 60.00 0.33 0.67 1.00 100.36 10 −5.00 40.00 35.00 −0.08 0.67 0.58 100.44 11 −35.00 40.00 5.00 −0.58 0.67 0.08 101.03 12 43.20 40.00 83.20 0.72 0.67 1.39 100.31 13 43.80 40.00 83.80 0.73 0.67 1.40 99.58 14 −6.80 40.00 33.20 −0.11 0.67 0.55 99.69 15 8.60 40.00 48.60 0.14 0.67 0.81 99.55 Total MWH 0.45 8.67 9.12 EGT, ES, Battery Only, and GTG Only Comparison

Table 2 entitled “Hybrid Energy System Example Configurations” below provides an example of an EGT configuration, an ES configuration, a Battery storage only configuration, and a GTG only configuration. As shown in Table 2, the EGT configuration is a substantial improvement over the GTG only configuration in that the operating range is extended at the lower end by approximately 50% and provides for emissions-free, electric grid reliability products until such time as the GTG is actually needed to respond to a reliability event. As further evidenced by Table 2, the ES configuration is a substantial improvement over the battery only in that its operating range is extended by approximately 50% at the upper end and provides for extended operating times.

TABLE 2 Hybrid Energy System Example Configurations Enhanced Battery Gas GTG Enhanced Storage Turbine (EGT) Storage (ES) Only Only Pmin 0.1 MW  −50 MW −50 MW  25 MW Pmax 49 MW  99 MW 50 MW 49 MW Primary 49 MW  99 MW 50 MW 24 MW Frequency Response Emissions-Free 10 MVAR 50 MVAR 50 MVAR 0 MVAR Voltage Regulation Emissions-Free 49 MW  99 MW 50 MW  0 MW Spinning Reserve Energy Output 49 MW 99 MW for 4 50 MW 49 MW for hours, 49 MW for 4 for unlimited for unlimited hours unlimited hours hours hours Energy Heat 9,850 Market heat Market 9,850 Rate, rate capped at rate BTU/kWh approximately 12,000 ES Transient Response

FIG. 4 illustrates a transient response of an ES hybrid energy system configuration having a 50 MW GTG and a storage device having a 50 MW stored energy capacity compared to a 100 MW gas turbine only system. The ES hybrid energy system configuration is used for example and should not be construed as limiting the present subject matter to only such a configuration. FIG. 4 illustrates a plot 50 of a 0.3 hertz (Hz) frequency drop when a hybrid energy system and a gas turbine only system are on-line. As shown in plot 50, the ES hybrid energy system output 52 provides a faster primary frequency response than the 100 MW gas turbine only system output 54. As designed by industry standards, improved primary frequency response from the ES hybrid energy system is worth approximately three times that of an average synchronous GTG re-dispatched. As such, FIG. 4 illustrates that the ES hybrid energy system provides at least two times the frequency regulation service than the 100 MW gas turbine only system.

During periods when an electrical grid is operating within its normal operating limits, the gas fired generation system can remain off-line, such that primary transient protection can be from a storage system. If the storage system is required by the electrical grid to operate for transient protection, the gas fired generator (e.g., gas turbine) can start, such as substantially instantaneously, and at least a portion of a storage load of the storage system can be transferred to the gas fired generator upon synchronization of the gas fired generator. The storage output of the energy storage system does not need to be additive to the gas turbine output, but rather provides (e.g., substantially instantaneously) output until the gas turbine can deliver the necessary output. That is, the energy storage system can be slaved to the gas fired generation output such that the energy storage system discharges the difference between the facility Pmax and the actual gas fired generation output, on a net basis.

In FIG. 5, another example of a hybrid generation grid support system response time plot is shown, with the y-axis representing power output in megawatts (MW) and the x-axis representing elapsed time in minutes. Although, specific gas turbine power output, storage power output, and times are shown, they are to be understood as exemplary only and do not limit the current disclosure. As shown, from time 0 minutes to time 5 minutes the gas turbine's generator is in an off-line condition (60). During the same time period, the energy storage system produces 50 MW of energy output (64). Although FIG. 5 illustrates the energy storage capacity equal to the total facility output, embodiments are not so limited. For example, the energy storage capacity can be greater than the total facility output.

In the example illustrated in FIG. 5, at time 0 minutes a transient event occurs. As described herein, substantially instantaneously upon detection of the transient event the HMS may control the energy storage system to substantially immediately respond with its full output, drawing power from the energy storage system while the gas turbine initiates its start sequence (60). The gas turbine generator synchronization and loading profile (62) can be seen in FIG. 5 beginning at time 5 minutes. Once the gas turbine has completed its start sequence and is synchronized (time 5 minutes), the HMS will reduce the load drawn from the energy storage system at a rate that is inversely proportion to the net gas turbine generator output. That is, the HMS may control the power output by the energy storage system so that the slopes of the output of the energy storage system and the gas turbine generator from time 5 minutes to time 10 minutes are substantially equal but opposite. Thus, at time 10 minutes when the gas turbine output is substantially equal to the total facility output (66) there is no longer any output from the energy storage system (68). In this manner, this method can provide substantially continuous and substantially immediate responses to a system transient and contingencies without at least a portion of the undesired attributes of unnecessary fuel burn, unwanted pollutants, and unrequired energy contributed by maintaining the gas turbine generator spinning in a hot standby mode as is typical for current gas fired generation units providing standby power for the grid.

Various embodiments enable the hybrid energy system to be operated in a number of configurations and manners to provide operators with economic advantages. For example, the HMS may use a life-cycle cost envelope that includes the financial impact of starting, cycling, and running the gas turbine at minimum load. For example, the variable operating cost of running the hybrid energy system at its super-low Pmin can be used to partially offset the avoided cost of buying parasitic load at retail rates and the value of spinning or flexible capacity.

In electric markets with variable pricing, the feed-forward loop of the HMS may take inputs from at least one of Day-Ahead (DA) market awards, schedules, prices, DA load forecasts, Variable Energy Resource (VER) forecasts, GT/battery life-cycle, and operational envelopes, so as to provide an initial DA Expected Delivery Schedule (DA EDS), as illustrated in FIG. 6. The DA EDS may then be updated as required with information from the Real Time market (RT EDS) as illustrated in FIG. 7. The RT data may have a time horizon of one hour, two hour, three hour, four hour, five hour, six hour, seven hour, eight hour, nine hour, ten hour or more, which will run periodically, such as anywhere from about 5 seconds to 20 minutes or more, to correct the plan based upon at least one of the RT market awards, schedules and prices, RT load forecasts and RT VER forecasts and the GT/battery life-cycle and operational envelopes at intervals, such as about 5 hr, 4 hr, 3 hr, 2 hr, 1 hr, 15 minutes, or 5 minutes.

The initial expected energy schedule can be modified in real time by the feedback loop of the HMS, which takes inputs from the Operator or from the market awards for product type (e.g., energy, ancillary services, flex-ramp) which can govern at least one of the applied ramp rates, Dispatch Operating Target (DOT), 15 minute trajectory, plant control system for the current operator set-point for net plant output, battery SOC, GTG output, and actual plant net output. Once again, the HMS will be directed by the operator in response to market instruction from the bids and schedules per the off-take agreement or RT instructions per the Operator and the optimization effort may ensure the unit is positioned to ensure any contractual terms are met while minimizing capital costs, for example.

In an example, the HMS may deliver DA and RT availability and pricing information for energy and capacity products to the Scheduling Coordinator (SC).

Life-cycle costs can vary. For example, faster ramp rates can cost more than slower ramps. Therefore, the HMS may match the specific needs on a lowest emissions or least cost basis. The hybrid facility may include a number of ramping profiles depending whether the gas turbine is running or not and whether the response is from the GTG only, battery only, or a combined GTG and battery response. The fastest ramp rates may be reserved for primary frequency response and are a function of the gas turbine governor and battery inverter outside of and at a higher priority to the HMS optimizations. For example, Table 3 lists 25 exemplary ramping profiles, and FIG. 8 illustrates example ramp trajectories.

TABLE 3 Exemplary Ramping Profiles Battery & Battery GTG only GTG and GT Ramp Rate Battery GTG only from from from GT MW/Min only from S/D Pmin GTG S/D Pmin Lowest 3.33 3.33 3.33 6.67 6.67 Low 12.50 3.33 5.00 15.83 17.50 Med 25.00 5.00 10.00 30.00 35.00 High 37.50 7.50 15.00 45.00 52.50 Highest 50.00 10.00 20.00 60.00 70.00

Primary frequency response may be dampened for a portion or the entire facility by the Power System Stabilizer (PSS). For all other products, the HMS may restrict the use of the gas-fired generation to only those periods where it is needed to support grid reliability or respond to user defined economic signals. The HMS may start and stop the gas turbine as required is such a way as to keep the output linear as required.

The feedback loop of the HMS receives, as its primary inputs, the RT instruction from the Operator and the RT plant net output. A final optimization may be performed using a time horizon, such as a 5 minute time horizon, a 10 minute time horizon, a 15 minute time horizon, or a 20 minute or longer time horizon, as shown in FIG. 9. This final optimization may allow the HMS to correct for any deviations from the RT EDS and will issue the final outputs to the battery inverters and gas turbine necessary to meet the Operator instruction. During this optimization, the HMS will make the final decision and issue instructions to start and stop the gas turbine, charge the battery, and ramp the plant at specified ramp rates.

The batteries may be charged by the gas turbine during periods where a null output from facility is desired but the intertemporal value of gas fired generation will be needed in a later period either for reliability or economic energy. This mill period can occur somewhat frequently for short durations of time, such as about 5 minutes to about 15 minutes, when the facility up to full load. If desired, the hybrid facility may respond to a short real time price drop such as those produced by variations from renewable resources, or overlapping ramps of thermal generation by simply directing all GT power to the battery, avoiding the cycle costs on the GT, until the event has concluded.

The HMS may optimize the energy delivery and SOC in such a way as to deliver energy in the least cost manner, but also for the longest period of time. For example, the HMS may use the RT EDS, current day gas prices and current RT energy prices to determine if a dispatch instruction to part load (50% for example) should be met by the battery only, the GT only, or a combination of battery and GT. Limiting the battery output in one interval will extend its ability to deliver in the next interval. In this example, the facility energy pricing may be viewed as either aggregate or individual pricing of battery and GT over the time horizon.

In another example, the HMS may determine whether the transition energy produced by the GT during its normal ramping should be delivered to the grid or to the battery in order to extend the battery range. This may be accomplished on both positive and negative ramps.

Products provided by the hybrid energy system may include: inertia or primary frequency response, voltage support, energy, capacity for flexible ramping (as required for renewable integration), preventive or corrective capacity, and ancillary services.

The HMS may manage the facility output based on a number of factors, including but not limited in scope or order:

-   -   1. Grid reliability         -   a. Local Grid Reliability needs             -   i. Primary frequency control             -   ii. Secondary frequency control             -   iii. Voltage support             -   iv. Preventive Capacity (N-1)             -   v. Corrective Capacity (N-1-1)         -   b. Area Grid Reliability             -   i. Ramping energy             -   ii. Regulation             -   iii. Spinning Reserve     -   2. Emissions reductions         -   a. The hybrid operating range allows the maximum headroom             for green renewables operating as Variable Energy Resources             (VER) to produce at their maximum output without             curtailment. The hybrid facility may respond with negative             or positive output to provide:             -   i. Flexible ramping up during periods when VER output                 dips.             -   ii. Flexible ramping down during periods where VER                 output increases.     -   3. Economic energy.         -   a. The hybrid operating range allows the maximum headroom             for the lowest cost energy by responding in real time with             negative or positive energy prices based upon:             -   i. Arbitraged storage price—storage only output.             -   ii. Aggregate arbitraged storage price and gas-fired                 heat rate—storage and gas-fired output.             -   iii. Gas-fired heat rate—gas-fired output only.             -   iv. Aggregate gas-fired heat rate—gas-fired and storage                 output when storage was charged with gas fired                 generator.

The HMS may optimize on the maximum usage of the storage system that facilitates the minimum amount of gas burned from the gas turbine to meet the priorities of: 1) reliability, 2) emissions reductions, or 3) economic energy. This decision process may aid in meeting an off-take agreement or other contractual terms and conditions, while protecting investment (e.g., capital) in the hybrid energy system. This optimization may include at a minimum, the following inputs:

-   -   1. Primary frequency response demand from plant sensors and         power system stabilizer.     -   2. Local area inertia need—discrete out of market schedule or         dispatch by ISO.     -   3. Preventive capacity (N-1)—discrete out of market schedule or         dispatch by ISO.     -   4. Corrective capacity (N-1-1)—discrete out of market schedule         or dispatch by ISO.     -   5. Economic market signals.         -   a. Day ahead and Real Time market pricing for energy and             ancillary services.         -   b. Day ahead Real Time load forecasts.         -   c. DA and Real time Variable Energy Resource (VER)             forecasts.         -   d. Flexible ramping—intertemporal price signal to cover net             load changes caused by VER.     -   6. Gas Prices Variable operating costs of hybrid facility.     -   7. Life cycle maintenance cost constraints—storage system.         -   a. Life cycle maintenance cost constraints—gas-fired             generation.             Application of a Hybrid Energy System (Hybrid System)

As discussed herein, the hybrid system can also be used in various industrial and/or islanding power applications (e.g., an isolated bus). In industrial and/or islanding power applications, gas turbine generator sets (e.g., more than one gas turbine generator such as two gas turbine generators) can be subjected to large routine load swings. As an example, in mining operations, the load swings can be attributed to the descending and ascending equipment. The power required for the load swing generally isn't consistent but instead increases and decreases rapidly and intermittently. These load swings can be difficult to manage and can lead to problems with power quality as well as reliability from unit trips and accelerated wear of engine components, which lead to high life cycle costs.

In order to maintain reliability, previous approaches have an additional gas turbine running at a minimum load or sharing some portion of the load. While this arrangement protects reliability by allowing load to be picked up by a second gas turbine should the one gas turbine trip off-line, it also requires that one or both of the gas turbines to be run at a lower load, which is less efficient.

In an example, a hybrid system of the present disclosure can be used in industrial and/or islanding power applications to allow the gas turbines to run most efficiently, improve economics and minimize accelerated wear of the engine components. FIG. 10A illustrates a block diagram of one example of a hybrid energy system 70, according to the present disclosure. The hybrid energy system 70 includes two or more gas turbine generators (GTG) 72, 74 and one or more storage devices 76 that can provide power to an application 78 such as an industrial and/or islanding power application. The GTGs 72, 74 can be the GTG 12 described in FIG. 1 and the storage device 76 can be the storage device 14 described in FIG. 1. In an example, GTG 72 can be a primary GTG and GTG 64 can be an additional or secondary GTG.

In one example, the application 78 is an application that is not connected to an electrical grid such as the electrical grid 20 in FIG. 1. While there are only two GTGs 72, 74 and one storage device 76 shown in FIG. 10A, any number of primary and secondary GTGs and storage devices can be used. As shown in FIG. 10A, the storage device 76 is coupled to the primary and secondary GTGs 72, 73. The system 70 shown in FIG. 10A allows the primary and secondary GTGs 72, 74 to be run at the most efficient operating point and remain at a stable load, while the storage device 76 can handle any load swing or a portion of the load swing.

In an example, one or more primary GTGs (e.g., primary GTG 72) can be configured to operate in a droop mode in order to handle load swings within ramp rate threshold, which is a predefined range of a load that the GTG 72 can provide such that the GTG 72 is stable. If the load swing is outside the ramp rate threshold, the storage device 76 can be configured to handle the entire load swing or the portion of the load swing outside of the ramp rate threshold. The stable load output for each GTG can vary and can be dependent on their application and other parameters. If the load swing is within the load swing threshold, the primary GTG 72 can provide the additional load. However, if the load swing is greater than or outside of the ramp rate threshold, the storage device 76 can provide the load to accommodate the load swing. In one example, the storage device 76 can provide the power to accommodate any load swing greater than the stable load output. In another example, the storage device 76 can provide the power to accommodate any load swing that is above the ramp rate threshold.

In an example with a system with a base load of 90 MW and a maximum load swing of +−10 MW where there are with three (3) gas turbines each rated for 50 MW and a 20 MW battery system (e.g., storage system), the hybrid system would have two (2) gas turbines running at 45 MW and one gas turbine shut-down in a stand-by mode, and the storage system would manage all load swings. Thus, the hybrid system 70 allows the one or more primary GTGs 72 to operate at the stable load even when there is a load swing because the storage device 76 can provide the power for the extra load.

In another example, in the event that the primary GTG 72 goes off-line, e.g., trips or has maintenance, the storage device 76 can support all critical loads until the secondary GTG (such as GTG 74) is brought on-line. Thus, the secondary GTG 74 does not need to be running at a minimum load just in case the primary GTG 72 trips or goes off line. The system 70 in FIG. 10A protects reliability by having the storage device 76 ready to provide an immediate response if the primary GTG 72 trips off-line, but also provides fuel savings and reduced maintenance cycles on the GTGs 72, 74.

In another example, a CCGT hybrid system of the present disclosure can be used in industrial and/or islanding power applications to allow the gas and steam turbines to run most efficiently, improve economics and minimize accelerated wear of the engine components while meeting electric grid transient response expectations. FIG. 10B illustrates a block diagram of an example of a CCGT hybrid energy system 80, according to the present disclosure. The CCGT hybrid energy system 80 includes two or more gas turbine generators (GTG) 81, 82 configured to direct exhaust gasses 83 to a steam generator 84 that generates steam from the waste heat in the exhaust gases and provides the steam to a steam turbine generator (STG) 85. The CCGT hybrid energy system 80 further includes one or more storage devices 86. In the CCGT hybrid energy system 80 the power output of the two or more GTGs 81, 82, the STG 85, and the one or more storage devices 86 are electrical connected on the same side to a stepup transformer 88. The GTGs 81, 82 can be the GTG 12 described with reference to FIG. 1, the storage device 86 can be the storage device 14 described with reference to FIG. 1, and the stepup transformer 88 can be the transformer 16 described with reference to FIG. 1.

While there are only two GTGs 81, 82, one STG 85, and one storage device 86 shown in FIG. 10B, any number of GTGs, STGs and storage devices can be used. The system 80 shown in FIG. 10B allows the GTGs 81, 82 and STG 85 to be run at the most efficient operating point and remain at a stable load, while the storage device 86 can handle any load swing or a portion of the load swing, including accommodating turbine lag of the STG 85 as described herein (see FIG. 13).

FIG. 11 illustrates a plot of the power output of a standard system. The plot includes the power output (MW) on the y-axis and the time (min) on the x-axis for two GTGs (e.g., a primary GTG (GT1) and a secondary GTG (GT2)). Line 90 represents the primary GTG's output and line 92 represents the secondary GTG output. As seen in FIG. 11, the primary GTG's output (line 90) remains constant and the secondary GTG's output (line 92) fluctuates and changes with the load swings corresponding to the variable power needs. That is, during operation, the secondary GTG is running at a minimum in order to be ready to provide the power for any load swings. By doing so, the secondary GTG is run inefficiently and can increase cost and accelerate the wear on the secondary GTG.

In contrast to FIG. 11, FIG. 12 is a plot of the power output of a hybrid energy system (e.g., hybrid system 70 shown in FIG. 10A), according to the present disclosure. The plot includes the power output (MW) on the y-axis and the time (min) on the x-axis for two GTGs (primary GTG (GT1); line 80 and secondary GTG (GT2); line 84), the storage device (Battery; line 86), and the net plant output (i.e., the GTG output plus the battery output; line 82). As seen in FIG. 12, the secondary GTG (line 84) can remain offline while the storage device (line 86) can be used to provide the additional power for any load swings. Thus, the hybrid system 70 can maintain reliability by having the storage device 76 provide an immediate response to the primary GTG 72 going off-line. The secondary GTG 74 will only start if the primary GTG 72 goes offline In that instance, the storage device 76 will provide the initial power until the secondary GTG 74 is up and running.

In an example system with a base load of 90 MW and a maximum load swing of +−10 MW where there are with three (3) gas turbines each rated for 50 MW and a 20 MW battery system (e.g., storage system), the hybrid system would maintain reliability if one of the two (2) gas turbines went off-line. For example, the storage system could provide the power for the extra load that the gas turbine that went off-line was provided until the third gas turbine could be started. Further, the hybrid system could also run the two gas turbines at a load of between 45 MW and 50 MW as required to charge the battery.

CCGT generator systems provide greater efficiency (and thus reduced emissions of greenhouse gasses) by capturing the waste heat of the gas turbine generator to generate steam that drives a steam turbine generator (STG). This benefit may require the compromise of a slower response to increases in electric grid demand because of the lag involved in increasing steam generation in the heat exchanger from the increase in heat in the gas turbine exhaust gasses and the lag of the steam turbine responding to the increased steam energy, collectively referred to as STG turbine lag. This can be seen in FIG. 13, which illustrates responses by the gas and steam turbine generators (TG) to an increase in grid power demand followed by a decrease in grid power demand. FIG. 13 is a plot of the power output of a CCGT hybrid energy system (e.g., the CCGT hybrid system 80 shown in FIG. 10B) including two GTGs and one STG, according to the present disclosure. In the example illustrated in FIG. 13, the two GTGs are operated at the same power level at all times, so their respective power outputs appear as a single line on the plot.

In the example power transients illustrated in FIG. 13, the CCGT is initially operating at a low power state providing 230 megawatts (read off the left vertical axis) to the grid at an initial condition at time 0. This power output is supplied in part 1302 by the two GTGs (each GTG generating 57 MW read off the right vertical axis) and in part 1304 by the STG (116 MW read off the right vertical axis) capturing energy from the waste heat in the exhaust gasses of the two GTGs.

In response to an increase in grid demand power at time 1 minute, the two GTGs can promptly begin to respond by ramping up power along the ramping profile 1306, enabling the net output power of the CCGT generator system to exhibit an output power ramping profile 1310. The two GTG reach their target power output 1312 of 165 MW in about 9 minutes. However, the STG follows a different power output profile 1308 as the amount of steam generated from waste heat of the two GTGs builds up and the STG power output responds to the steam increase. Again, this delay between the GTG responses to a power demand increase and the corresponding response of the STG is referred to as the STG turbine lag. The STG turbine lag in power output of the STG results in a temporary shortfall of power output 1310 by the CCTG generator system compared to the power expected by the grid or demand power (shown in the dashed line 1313) as illustrated in hashed portion 1314.

In various embodiments, the HMS controls the CCTG generator system and the energy storage device to use power from the energy storage to supplement the net power output 1310 of the CCGT generator system so as to satisfy the full electric grid demand 1313 during the STG turbine lag, effectively making up for the power output shortfall 1314 until the CCGT generator system net output reaches the target (e.g., full power) output 1318 of about 530 MW. This enables the output of the hybrid CCTG generator system to appear to the grid as if the system is a GTG system (i.e., the power output response to the up-power transient is consistent with that of a pure GTG system). As electric grids are configured to expect gas turbine peaking power plants to follow load changes like typical GTG response curves, various embodiments enable the use of more efficient CCTG generator systems in peaking power plants while meeting the expected power response for such plants. In some embodiments, the energy storage device may be sized to satisfy the total amount of power difference between the maximum power output of the system and the combined power output by the two GTGs and the STG before the STG reaches its maximum power output under a worst case transient (e.g., from minimum power to full power).

The HMS may control the CCTG generator system and the energy storage device to use power from the energy storage device to supplement the net power output 1310 of the CCGT generator system by connecting the energy storage device to the step-up transformer in parallel with the CCTG generator system (i.e., the power outputs of both GTGs and the STG) and controlling the current flowing from the energy storage device so that the net power output of the CCGT hybrid energy system closely matches the power demand of the electric grid. When the net power generated by the two GTGs and the STG matches the power demand of the electric grid, the energy storage device may be disconnected from the step-up transformer.

Turbine lag by the STG portion of the CCTG generator system also occurs during down-power transients because steam generated by the waste heat in GTG exhaust gasses decreases slower than the power output of the two GTGs due to heat stored in the system (e.g., within steam in the system and in the structures of the heat exchanger). Thus, while the down-power profile 1316 of each GTG is rapid, reaching a target output (57 MW) in about 8 minutes, the STG follows a slower down-power profile 1320. As a result, the CCTG generator system exhibits a down-power profile 1324 that produces excess of power (shown in hashed region 1326) beyond what the electric grid anticipates (i.e., beyond the power output of a pure GTG system) for a period of time (approximately 12 minutes in the illustrated example) before the CCGT net output reaches steady state 1328 at the new demand power (about 230 MW). In some embodiments, the HMS is configured to use this excess power output 1326 from the STG due to STG turbine lag to recharge the energy storage device.

The HMS may control the CCTG system and the energy storage device to use excess power output 1326 from the STG due to STG turbine lag to recharge the energy storage device by connecting the energy storage device to the STG output in parallel with the step-up transformer at least when the GTG has reached steady state at the new power level and controlling the current flowing to the energy storage device so that the net power output of the CCGT hybrid energy system closely matches the down-power profile of a GTG. When the net power generated by the two GTGs and the STG matches the power demand of the electric grid, the energy storage device may be disconnected from the STG.

This operation thus reduces the total power output of the CCGT generator system (indicated by dashed line 1330) to a profile consistent with that of a GTG system. Additionally, this operation recharges the energy storage device so that power is available to support the next increase in power demand (i.e., up-power transient) by the grid. This recovery of excess power due to the STG turbine lag during down-power transients also increases the efficiency of the overall CCGT generator system (and thus further reduces greenhouse gas emissions) because less power is required from the system or the grid to maintain the power state of the energy storage device.

EXAMPLES

Example 1 can include subject matter (such as an apparatus, a method, a means for performing acts, or a machine readable medium including instructions that, when performed by the machine, that can cause the machine to perform acts), such as a hybrid energy system, comprising: a generator step-up transformer; a gas turbine generator (GTG) configured to provide a full-load power output; and a storage device configured to store energy, wherein the GTG and the storage device are electrically co-located on a low side of the generator step-up transformer.

Example 2 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of Example 1 to optionally include wherein the GTG is a fast start GTG.

Example 3 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1 or 2 to optionally include wherein the storage device is configured to be charged by an electric grid if a grid market price is lower than a GTG charging cost.

Example 4 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-3 to optionally include wherein the storage device is configured to be charged by the GTG if a GTG charging cost is lower than a grid market cost.

Example 5 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-4 to optionally include wherein the hybrid energy system is configured to start the GTG from a stand-by state and ramp the GTG to a desired power output of the hybrid energy system in about 20 minutes or less, wherein the desired power output of the hybrid energy system is not greater than the full-load power output.

Example 6 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-5 to optionally include wherein the hybrid energy system is configured to ramp the GTG in response to a frequency disturbance.

Example 7 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-6 to optionally include wherein the GTG is off-line in the stand-by-state.

Example 8 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-7 to optionally include wherein the storage device is configured to be charged by an electric grid.

Example 9 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-8 to optionally include wherein the storage device has as stored energy capacity at least about 5% of the full-load power output up to about 100% of the full-load power output.

Example 10 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-9 to optionally include wherein the storage device includes an inverter-rectifier having stored energy of at least about 10% of the full-load power output.

Example 11 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-10 to optionally include wherein the total hybrid energy system is configured to start the GTG from the stand-by state to the desired power output of the hybrid energy system and discharge at least a portion of the stored energy of the storage device at a hybrid ramp rate that substantially matches in a gas-turbine alone ramp rate.

Example 12 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-11 to optionally include a ramping profile of the hybrid energy system continually increases until the desired power output of the hybrid energy system is obtained.

Example 13 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-12 to optionally include wherein a state of charge of the storage device is configured to vary less than 5% during operation of the hybrid energy system.

Example 14 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-13 to optionally include wherein a stored energy capacity of the storage device is at least equal to the full-load power output of the GTG.

Example 15 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-14 to optionally include wherein the stored energy capacity of the storage device has at least about 1 hour of stored energy discharge beyond the full-load power output of the GTG.

Example 16 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-15 to optionally include wherein the storage device is configured to respond before the GTG when an event is detected during the operation of the hybrid energy system.

Example 17 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-16 to optionally include wherein the hybrid energy system is configured to respond to an electric grid demand.

Example 18 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-17 to optionally include wherein hybrid energy system is configured to respond to the electric grid demand without producing any pollutants.

Example 19 can include subject matter (such as an apparatus, a method, a means for performing acts, or a machine readable medium including instructions that, when performed by the machine, that can cause the machine to perform acts), such as a hybrid energy system, comprising: a generator step-up transformer; a gas turbine generator (GTG) configured to provide a full-load power output and having a minimum power output of less than 5% of the full-load power output; and a storage device configured to store energy, wherein: the GTG and the storage device are electrically co-located on a low side of the generator step-up transformer, and a stored energy capacity of the storage device is at least about 5% of the full-load power output up to about 100% of the full-load power output.

Example 20 can include subject matter (such as an apparatus, a method, a means for performing acts, or a machine readable medium including instructions that, when performed by the machine, that can cause the machine to perform acts), such as a hybrid energy system, comprising: a generator step-up transformer; a gas turbine generator (GTG) configured to provide a full-load power output; and a storage device configured to store energy, wherein: the GTG and the storage device are electrically co-located on a low side of the generator step-up transformer, the storage device is configured to be charged based on at least one market factor, and the hybrid energy system is configured to provide a substantially emissions free ramping of energy.

Example 21 can include subject matter (such as an apparatus, a method, a means for performing acts, or a machine readable medium including instructions that, when performed by the machine, that can cause the machine to perform acts), such as a hybrid energy system, comprising: a generator step-up transformer; a gas turbine generator (GTG) configured to provide a full-load power output; and a storage device configured to store energy, wherein: the GTG and the storage device are electrically co-located on a low side of the generator step-up transformer, where a GTG output in excess of a required regulation output is diverted to charging the storage device to maintain a state of charge of the storage device within a specified threshold of a target state of charge.

Example 22 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-21 to optionally include wherein the specified threshold of the target state of charge is less than two Megawatt hours from the target state of charge.

Example 23 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-22 to optionally include where the specified threshold of the target state of charge is less than one Megawatt hour from the target state of charge.

Example 24 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-23 to optionally include where a state of charge of the storage device is configured to vary less than five percent during the operation of the hybrid energy system.

Example 25 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-24 to optionally include where the GTG output in excess of the required regulation output is determined by a difference between the GTG output and the second regulation ramping output.

Example 26 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-25 to optionally include where the first regulation output is greater than the second regulation output.

Example 27 can include, or can optionally be combined with the subject matter of one or any combination of Examples 1-26 to optionally include where the first regulation output is less than the second regulation output.

Example 28 can include subject matter (such as an apparatus, a method, a means for performing acts, or a machine readable medium including instructions that, when performed by the machine, that can cause the machine to perform acts), such as a hybrid energy system, comprising: a generator step-up transformer; a gas turbine generator (GTG) configured to provide up to a full-load power output; and a storage device configured to store energy, wherein: the GTG and the storage device are electrically co-located on a low side of the generator step-up transformer, where wherein the storage device is configured to maintain a state of charge within a specified threshold of a target state of charge.

Example 29 can include a method, comprising responding to a change in a regulation ramping output from a first regulation ramping output to a second regulation ramping output with the hybrid energy system, the hybrid energy system, including: a generator step-up transformer; a gas turbine generator (GTG) configured to provide up to a full-load power output; and a storage device configured to store energy, wherein the GTG and the storage device are electrically co-located on a low side of the generator step-up transformer; and diverting excess energy beyond the second regulation output to charge the storage device such that a state of charge of the storage device is maintained within a specified threshold of a target state of charge.

Each of these non-limiting examples can stand on its own, or can be combined in any permutation or combination with any one or more of the other examples.

The above detailed description includes references to the accompanying drawings, which form a part of the detailed description. The drawings show, by way of illustration, specific embodiments in which the invention can be practiced. These embodiments are also referred to herein as “examples.” Such examples can include elements in addition to those shown or described. However, the present inventors also contemplate examples in which only those elements shown or described are provided. Moreover, the present inventors also contemplate examples using any combination or permutation of those elements shown or described (or one or more aspects thereof), either with respect to a particular example (or one or more aspects thereof), or with respect to other examples (or one or more aspects thereof) shown or described herein.

In the event of inconsistent usages between this document and any documents so incorporated by reference, the usage in this document controls. In this document, the terms “a” or “an” are used, as is common in patent documents, to include one or more than one, independent of any other instances or usages of “at least one” or “one or more.” In this document, the term “or” is used to refer to a nonexclusive or, such that “A or B” includes “A but not B,” “B but not A,” and “A and B,” unless otherwise indicated. In this document, the terms “including” and “in which” are used as the plain-English equivalents of the respective terms “comprising” and “wherein.” Also, in the following claims, the terms “including” and “comprising” are open-ended, that is, a system, device, article, composition, formulation, or process that includes elements in addition to those listed after such a term in a claim are still deemed to fall within the scope of that claim. Moreover, in the following claims, the terms “first,” “second,” and “third,” etc. are used merely as labels, and are not intended to impose numerical requirements on their objects.

The term “substantially simultaneously” or “substantially immediately” or “substantially instantaneously” refers to events occurring at approximately the same time. It is contemplated by the inventor that response times can be limited by mechanical, electrical, or chemical processes and system. Substantially simultaneously, substantially immediately, or substantially instantaneously can include time periods 1 minute or less, 45 seconds or less, 30 seconds or less, 20 seconds or less, 15 seconds or less, 10 seconds or less, 5 seconds or less, 3 seconds or less, 2 seconds or less, 1 second or less, 0.5 seconds or less, or 0.1 seconds or less.

Method examples described herein can be machine or computer-implemented at least in part. Some examples can include a computer-readable medium or machine-readable medium encoded with instructions operable to configure an electronic device to perform methods as described in the above examples. An implementation of such methods can include code, such as microcode, assembly language code, a higher-level language code, or the like. Such code can include computer readable instructions for performing various methods. The code may form portions of computer program products. Further, in an example, the code can be tangibly stored on one or more volatile, non-transitory, or non-volatile tangible computer-readable media, such as during execution or at other times. Examples of these tangible computer-readable media can include, but are not limited to, hard disks, removable magnetic disks, removable optical disks (e.g., compact disks and digital video disks), magnetic cassettes, memory cards or sticks, random access memories (RAMs), read only memories (ROMs), and the like.

The above description is intended to be illustrative, and not restrictive. For example, the above-described examples (or one or more aspects thereof) may be used in combination with each other. Other embodiments can be used, such as by one of ordinary skill in the art upon reviewing the above description. The Abstract is provided to comply with 37 C.F.R. § 1.72(b), to allow the reader to quickly ascertain the nature of the technical disclosure. It is submitted with the understanding that it will not be used to interpret or limit the scope or meaning of the claims. Also, in the above Detailed Description, various features may be grouped together to streamline the disclosure. This should not be interpreted as intending that an unclaimed disclosed feature is essential to any claim. Rather, inventive subject matter may lie in less than all features of a particular disclosed embodiment. Thus, the following claims are hereby incorporated into the Detailed Description as examples or embodiments, with each claim standing on its own as a separate embodiment, and it is contemplated that such embodiments can be combined with each other in various combinations or permutations. The scope of the invention should be determined with reference to the appended claims, along with the full scope of equivalents to which such claims are entitled. 

What is claimed is:
 1. A hybrid energy system, comprising: a step-up transformer; a Combined Cycle Gas Turbine (CCGT) system comprising: a gas turbine generator comprising a gas turbine coupled to a first generator; and a steam turbine generator comprising a heat exchanger configured to receive exhaust gases from the gas turbine to generate steam, a steam turbine configured to receive steam from the heat exchanger, and a second generator coupled to the steam turbine; a storage device configured to store energy; and a hybrid management system coupled to the CCGT generator system, the storage device, and the step-up transformer, wherein the CCGT generator system and the storage device are electrically co-located on a low side of the step-up transformer, and wherein the hybrid management system is configured to control the CCGT generator system and the storage device to use energy from the storage device to provide power to an electric grid to compensate for turbine lag of the steam turbine generator when the CCGT generator system responds to an increase in electric grid demand.
 2. The hybrid energy system of claim 1, wherein the hybrid management system is configured to control the CCGT generator system and the storage device to use energy from the storage device to provide power to the electric grid to compensate for turbine lag of the steam turbine generator when the CCGT generator system responds to an increase in electric grid demand so that total power output by the hybrid energy system to the electric grid follows a profile of a gas turbine power system responding to the increase in electric grid demand.
 3. The hybrid energy system of claim 1, wherein the hybrid management system is further configured to control the CCGT generator system and the storage device to direct excess energy produced by the steam turbine generator when the CCGT generator system responds to a decrease in electric grid demand to charging the storage device.
 4. The hybrid energy system of claim 3, wherein the hybrid management system is configured to control the CCGT generator system and the storage device such that using excess energy produced by the steam turbine generator when the CCGT generator system responds to a decrease in electric grid demand to charging the storage device results in total power output by the hybrid energy system to the electric grid following a profile of a gas turbine power system responding to the decrease in electric grid demand.
 5. A method of maintaining a state of charge of a storage device during operation of a hybrid energy system comprising a Combined Cycle Gas Turbine (CCGT) generator system including a gas turbine generator comprising a gas turbine coupled to a first generator, a steam turbine generator comprising a heat exchanger configured to receive exhaust gases from the gas turbine to generate steam, a steam turbine configured to receive steam from the heat exchanger, and a second generator coupled to the steam turbine, and a storage device configured to store energy, wherein the CCGT generator system and the storage device are electrically co-located on a low side of a step-up transformer, the method comprising: controlling, by a hybrid management system coupled to the CCGT generator system and the storage device, the CCGT generator system and the storage device to use energy from the storage device to provide power to an electric grid to compensate for turbine lag of the steam turbine generator when the CCGT generator system responds to an increase in electric grid demand.
 6. The method of claim 5, wherein controlling the CCGT generator system and the storage device to use energy from the storage device to provide power to the electric grid to compensate for turbine lag of the steam turbine generator when the CCGT generator system responds to an increase in electric grid demand comprises directing sufficient power to the electric grid to charging the storage device so that total power output by the hybrid energy system to the electric grid follows a profile of a gas turbine power system responding to the increase in electric grid demand.
 7. The method of claim 5, further comprising controlling, by the hybrid management system, the CCGT generator system and the storage device to direct excess energy produced by the steam turbine generator when the CCGT generator system responds to a decrease in electric grid demand to charging the storage device.
 8. The method of claim 7, wherein controlling, by the hybrid management system, the CCGT generator system and the storage device to direct excess energy produced by the steam turbine generator when the CCGT generator system responds to a decrease in electric grid demand to charging the storage device comprises directing sufficient power to charging the storage device so that total power output by the hybrid energy system to the electric grid follows a profile of a gas turbine power system responding to the decrease in electric grid demand. 